The Line
The Line
  • 1 098
  • 33 137 174
Muslim Caller Claims His Reasoning is "Logical For Him" | Matt Dillahunty & Seth Andrews
Original Episode Here: ua-cam.com/users/live_U1rK5Q28wo
Muslim caller Bob questions why the hosts don't believe in God, asserting that nothing can exist without God's permission. Matt repeatedly challenges Bob to justify his claims with evidence or logical arguments. The conversation becomes increasingly tense as Bob struggles to provide satisfactory responses, relying on personal belief and circular reasoning. Matt and Seth emphasize the importance of sound logical arguments and the burden of proof in discussions about God's existence. The call ends with Matt advising Bob to research and develop a proper syllogism before calling back.
SUPPORT THE NETWORK
---------------------------------------------------
Patreon: www.patreon.com/CallTheLine
Become a Channel Member:
SUPPORT PRODUCTION
---------------------------------------------------
Paypal: www.paypal.me/mratheist
Cashapp: cash.app/$jimmyasnow
Amazon Wishlist: www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/3AXN5GUWNFFYA
MORE LIVE SHOWS & CLIPS
---------------------------------------------------
www.youtube.com/@callthelinex
CONTACT US
---------------------------------------------------
contact@qnaline.com
HOSTS
---------------------------------------------------
Jimmy Snow: @JimmySnow
Matt Dillahunty: @SansDeity
Arden Hart: theardenhart
Katy Montgomerie: @KatyMontgomerie
Forrest Valkai: @RenegadeScienceTeacher
Dr. Ben: @FamilyDrBen
Aron Ra: @AronRa
Shannon Q: @ShannonQ
John Gleason: @godlessengineer
Erika: @GutsickGibbon
Eve Was Framed: eve_wasframed
Paulogia: @paulogia
Alyssa Ljub: @AlyssaLjub
Eric: @skepticsandscoundrels
Dr. Aaron Adair
ADDRESS
---------------------------------------------------
The Line
110 N Interstate 35
Suite 315-1027
Round Rock, TX 78681
United States
SHOWS ON THE LINE
---------------------------------------------------
Sundays: The Sunday Show
Monday: Skeptalk
Tuesday: Chewed Gum
Wednesday: The Hang Up
Thursday: The Trans Atlantic Call In Show (TACIS)
Friday: Debates and Bonus Shows!
Look out for “HOSTility” and “Cus I Wanna” any day, any time
#CallTheLine
Переглядів: 24 274

Відео

Caller Resorts to BIGOTRY When His Argument Can't Hold Up | Eve was Framed & Arden Hart
Переглядів 32 тис.4 години тому
Original Episode Here: ua-cam.com/users/liveciNHWq04FFk?feature=share Christian caller Jackie attempts to argue for the existence of God using the cosmological argument. The hosts challenge Jackie's premises and reasoning throughout the conversation, leading to debates on the nature of reality, truth, and causality. Key points of contention include Jackie's use of Occam's Razor, claims about li...
Caller Attempts to Grill Shannon on Her Reasons for Atheism, But Get's Grilled In Return w/ Will McC
Переглядів 30 тис.4 години тому
Original Episode Here: ua-cam.com/users/liveDiKjdqi0NsE Caller Anthony engages Shannon and Will in a spirited discussion about Christianity and the reasons behind Shannon's journey to atheism. The conversation turns contentious as they examine the reliability of the Gospels, with Anthony citing the early church historian Papias to argue for eyewitness accounts. Shannon and Will challenge this c...
"Atheism is a Malfunction" - When They Can't Defend They Attack - Forrest Valkai & Paulogia
Переглядів 49 тис.7 годин тому
Original Episode Here: ua-cam.com/users/liveOva8Jxsm-Fc A theist caller argues for God as a mental construct that serves to unify societies, suggesting atheism lacks this cohesive power. Hosts challenge the notion that social utility proves truth, pointing out secular societies' success and atheism's growth. Debate covers religion's historical impact, including negative aspects like genocide. H...
GOD Told This Caller to Present Us With His NDE | Matt Dillahunty & Eric (S&S)
Переглядів 35 тис.19 годин тому
GOD Told This Caller to Present Us With His NDE | Matt Dillahunty & Eric (S&S)
We Haven't Found Deep Enough Fox-Holes Yet! Matt Dillahunty & Eric (S&S)
Переглядів 37 тис.21 годину тому
We Haven't Found Deep Enough Fox-Holes Yet! Matt Dillahunty & Eric (S&S)
CALLER Defends Rationality of Faith Because of it's "Benefits" | Matt Dillahunty & Paulogia
Переглядів 32 тис.21 годину тому
CALLER Defends Rationality of Faith Because of it's "Benefits" | Matt Dillahunty & Paulogia
Caller Defends the Worst You Could Imagine | Forrest Valkai & Eric (S&S)
Переглядів 62 тис.День тому
Caller Defends the Worst You Could Imagine | Forrest Valkai & Eric (S&S)
"You Totally Railroaded Me!" Bigoted Trans Woman Doesn't Want to Be Held Accountable | Katy & Dr Ben
Переглядів 19 тис.14 днів тому
"You Totally Railroaded Me!" Bigoted Trans Woman Doesn't Want to Be Held Accountable | Katy & Dr Ben
Caller Clinging to Faith Despite What It's Put Her Through | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
Переглядів 24 тис.14 днів тому
Caller Clinging to Faith Despite What It's Put Her Through | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
Religion and Science Make SIMILAR Assumptions?? | Eve & Forrest Valkai
Переглядів 48 тис.14 днів тому
Religion and Science Make SIMILAR Assumptions?? | Eve & Forrest Valkai
This Caller Wants the Elimination of Desire?? Matt Dillahunty & Eve was Framed
Переглядів 30 тис.14 днів тому
This Caller Wants the Elimination of Desire?? Matt Dillahunty & Eve was Framed
Caller Asks How 1.4 Billion Theists Could ALL Be Wrong | Matt Dillahunty & Seth Andrews
Переглядів 55 тис.21 день тому
Caller Asks How 1.4 Billion Theists Could ALL Be Wrong | Matt Dillahunty & Seth Andrews
Christian Caller Thinks Objective Morality PROVES His God | Eve & Forrest Valkai
Переглядів 49 тис.21 день тому
Christian Caller Thinks Objective Morality PROVES His God | Eve & Forrest Valkai
Transphobic Liar is Upset That He's Being Held Accountable | Forrest Valkai and John Gleason
Переглядів 89 тис.21 день тому
Transphobic Liar is Upset That He's Being Held Accountable | Forrest Valkai and John Gleason
Caller's Journey Wrestling with Belief in God & the Supernatural | Jimmy Snow & Eric (S&S)
Переглядів 6 тис.21 день тому
Caller's Journey Wrestling with Belief in God & the Supernatural | Jimmy Snow & Eric (S&S)
Atheist Hosts SCHOOL Caller on Logic and Reasoning | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
Переглядів 50 тис.28 днів тому
Atheist Hosts SCHOOL Caller on Logic and Reasoning | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
Is Spiritual Pleasure SUPERIOR to Physical Pleasure?? | Eve was Framed & Alyssa Ljub
Переглядів 6 тис.Місяць тому
Is Spiritual Pleasure SUPERIOR to Physical Pleasure?? | Eve was Framed & Alyssa Ljub
"As Close to PROOF As You're Gonna Get!" | Matt Dillahunty and Dara the Magic Skeptic
Переглядів 39 тис.Місяць тому
"As Close to PROOF As You're Gonna Get!" | Matt Dillahunty and Dara the Magic Skeptic
Muslim Caller: "How can you see evolution billions of years ago?" | Forrest Valkai & Jesse Jerdak
Переглядів 72 тис.Місяць тому
Muslim Caller: "How can you see evolution billions of years ago?" | Forrest Valkai & Jesse Jerdak
Caller Struggles to Fully Grapple with Trans Identities | Arden Hart & Dr. Ben
Переглядів 8 тис.Місяць тому
Caller Struggles to Fully Grapple with Trans Identities | Arden Hart & Dr. Ben
Atheist Caller's BIZARRE Bible Interpretation Leaves Hosts Frustrated | Matt Dillahunty & Jimmy snow
Переглядів 40 тис.Місяць тому
Atheist Caller's BIZARRE Bible Interpretation Leaves Hosts Frustrated | Matt Dillahunty & Jimmy snow
Caller Claims ANYTHING God Commands Must Be Moral, Even the Worst | Shannon Q & Will McC
Переглядів 71 тис.Місяць тому
Caller Claims ANYTHING God Commands Must Be Moral, Even the Worst | Shannon Q & Will McC
Caller's Mormon God Encounter and Claims of Supernatural Healings | Jimmy Snow & Eric (S&S)
Переглядів 20 тис.Місяць тому
Caller's Mormon God Encounter and Claims of Supernatural Healings | Jimmy Snow & Eric (S&S)
Mountains of Evidence for Evolution Still Not Enough for This Creationist | Erika and Jackson Wheat
Переглядів 41 тис.Місяць тому
Mountains of Evidence for Evolution Still Not Enough for This Creationist | Erika and Jackson Wheat
Caller Claims Conspiracy Among Scientists to HIDE Evidence for God | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
Переглядів 129 тис.Місяць тому
Caller Claims Conspiracy Among Scientists to HIDE Evidence for God | Matt Dillahunty and Jimmy Snow
"That's a FAKE Bible" Caller Cries While Struggling to Defend Beliefs | Matt Dillahunty & Nick Fish
Переглядів 162 тис.Місяць тому
"That's a FAKE Bible" Caller Cries While Struggling to Defend Beliefs | Matt Dillahunty & Nick Fish
Caller Claims Complexity is Evidence of a Designer | Jimmy Snow and Eric Skeptics and Scoundrels
Переглядів 21 тис.Місяць тому
Caller Claims Complexity is Evidence of a Designer | Jimmy Snow and Eric Skeptics and Scoundrels
EMOTIONAL Man Struggles to Keep Composure While Defending Patriarchy | Alyssa Ljub & Erika GG
Переглядів 30 тис.Місяць тому
EMOTIONAL Man Struggles to Keep Composure While Defending Patriarchy | Alyssa Ljub & Erika GG
Theist Claims Existence Itself Is Evidence for God | Jimmy Snow & Forrest Valkai
Переглядів 66 тис.Місяць тому
Theist Claims Existence Itself Is Evidence for God | Jimmy Snow & Forrest Valkai

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @FuddlyDud
    @FuddlyDud 3 хвилини тому

    A couple thoughts on this: 1) If tribalism is a category above, then the superior tribe appears to be Christianity and we can get into numbers /history on this. 2) Mere tribalism doesn’t seem to justify social progress, for the moral values such as tolerance or charity for the outcast argued aren’t found in tribalism. Again, I can cite to the historical record on this fir successful progressive movements. The caller definitely made a category error, but I don’t think that stops the underlying foundation here from being right. :/

  • @jdm-uk-yank
    @jdm-uk-yank 3 хвилини тому

    Noah's kids had an argument = two religions.

  • @timcrowe8696
    @timcrowe8696 3 хвилини тому

    There isn’t anything stopping anyone from playing in the non-women only sports. If you want to play without filters play in the NBA, NFL, etc. if you’re good enough you’ll play, just like you’re requesting.

  • @SumNutOnU2b
    @SumNutOnU2b 4 хвилини тому

    I honestly think Skylar might have low level Tourette's

  • @sethfeldmann3204
    @sethfeldmann3204 4 хвилини тому

    I would like to remind everyone that this caller is Chuck the "my pronouns are attack/helicopter" guy that Forrest annihilated not too long ago.

  • @Wojacksamillion
    @Wojacksamillion 5 хвилин тому

    Sklyar waa ihu mg for usiing bad algnuage

  • @DaveCM
    @DaveCM 5 хвилин тому

    Dude read a couple of philosophy books, maybe listened to a a few people on UA-cam, and now he thinks he is a philosopher. Oh, and he has listened to some bad apologists.

  • @taketheatrain5393
    @taketheatrain5393 7 хвилин тому

    A former Mormon is simply a Forman. 😅

  • @akink9620
    @akink9620 8 хвилин тому

    Yes what are we going to talk about today eerrr let's try religion or the earths flat and what about tomorrow errr religion or the earths flat ETC

  • @MrSparkula
    @MrSparkula 9 хвилин тому

    If all rocks are made of dirt, why is there still dirt!

  • @psow4062
    @psow4062 10 хвилин тому

    I love Matt, but over the years of exposure to nonsense arguments he became kind of short tempered.

  • @flopperdilly2231
    @flopperdilly2231 10 хвилин тому

    Should've told Mohammad to watch this video when it gets posted and read the chat when he called to see all those who feel for his pain and want him to feel better and move forward with us.

  • @DarkAlkaiser
    @DarkAlkaiser 10 хвилин тому

    This is such a poor understanding of contradiction. It's still a contradiction even if you have an explanation as to why it happened. If the bible was written by a magic man aware of the future, there wouldn't be any of the stupid contradicitons needing terrible apologetics that often make no sense at all.

  • @ft3917
    @ft3917 19 хвилин тому

    there is no god. this is none sence

  • @mightymrmousempls
    @mightymrmousempls 22 хвилини тому

    Bro brought a ballon animal to a knife fight.

  • @jackgoff4668
    @jackgoff4668 22 хвилини тому

    I wonder if Matt is the bottom or Arden is the bottom?

  • @fightevil.readbooks.5076
    @fightevil.readbooks.5076 23 хвилини тому

    It's a "malfunction" to be a thinker. 😂😂😂

  • @elgringo1893
    @elgringo1893 24 хвилини тому

    As a Mr who is British, i am insulted by this callers insolence and we will shortly make him the only justified and successful extradited person to Rwanda

  • @TheCountBlackula1978
    @TheCountBlackula1978 24 хвилини тому

    Religious people smh they try they're best😂

  • @Sparky1701
    @Sparky1701 25 хвилин тому

    Eve: Do you care if what you believe is true? Do you care if something is true or not? Do you believe something can be true or not? Jackie: Yes I do. I do care. Eve: So do you want to believe in a god if it's not true? Jackie: If a god is not true, then I do not want to believe in a god Eve: Then why are you advocating that people should believe as though a god exists even if they don't knw if that's true or not... Short circuited thru all the bad apologetics and 'philosophy obfuscations' 'what is truth?' 'what is reality??' Jackie is- as Jimmy would say - a person in love with smelling their own farts. Eve is fast becoming one of the best 'debaters' as she cuts thru all the BS...

  • @TheCountBlackula1978
    @TheCountBlackula1978 25 хвилин тому

    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 weak sauce

  • @CynthiaMcCraw
    @CynthiaMcCraw 25 хвилин тому

    The more i watch Forrest the more I love him ❤

  • @toshir0m1
    @toshir0m1 27 хвилин тому

    Muslim callers are often very similar to christians who would *never* have heard any atheist argument ever. Completely naive and unprepared. That's insane to witness.

  • @Beastt17
    @Beastt17 27 хвилин тому

    How can Genesis be interpreted metaphorically without a timeline without just throwing away large parts of the text. Genesis is structured on a very deliberate timeline.

  • @BilliamJoyBoy
    @BilliamJoyBoy 30 хвилин тому

    Bryan has some reflection to do after that abysmal conversation. Literally can’t figure out how talking about how he can’t talk is ridiculous

  • @somegal-89
    @somegal-89 32 хвилини тому

    "What do you mean by reality" Dude what

  • @DarkAlkaiser
    @DarkAlkaiser 33 хвилини тому

    I didn't want to be an atheist, but I was quite happy to figure out the monster in the bible I genuinely believed in wasn't real. Sadly, I had morals of my own, and reading the bible quickly gave me no choice but to oppose him, no matter how impossible that opposition was, my morals didn't allow me to believe he was good despite the book claiming so over and over, his actions didn't match wit that goodness. So I was very pleased when I realized it made no sense in the first place, it was a good day. No, even if a gawd exists, I don't have to agree with their morals. It's kinda digusting this need said to people. If a gawd exists, there's nothing requiring they not be evil, even if they wrote a book that says they aren't evil.

  • @jackgoff4668
    @jackgoff4668 34 хвилини тому

    Didn't be trans, kids.

  • @meenotu859
    @meenotu859 34 хвилини тому

    Why do 'murican christians appropriate an argument made by muslims more than 1,000 years ago (about the time the western church (Rome) attempted to heal schisms within their delusional dogma with the eastern church (Byzantin) by launching the first of millennia of genecidal crusades against Islam) when we've learned so much over the last ~1,400 years. Who created the god? What is the "cause" of quantum entanglement? Is it righteous "JUSTICE" if the god sends itself to be crucified to appease itself cuz it's butthurt that it gave people minds with free will? Is the mustard seed actually the smallest seed the god created as it claimed? Why was there a zombie celebration when the god reanimated itself essentially plagiarizing from the god Osiris? Why did an unconditionally all godhead drown infants and their mothers? Is it actually wisdom to suggest murdering an infant to settle a dispute? Or psychopathy? On and on, round and round circular dogma is circular dogma is circular dogma, and a cult of hate is a cult of hate.....and there is no hatred as hateful as christian love.

  • @fozzy20
    @fozzy20 37 хвилин тому

    You can tell when they get these Brtish callers that they're always Muslims. Their weird accents give them away. They always have a weird lisp and nobody else from the UK would try to defend religion like they do. Source: Me, from the UK.

  • @kevin-en2pi
    @kevin-en2pi 38 хвилин тому

    According to the poll, just over half of scientists (51%) believe in some form of deity or higher power; specifically, 33% of scientists say they believe in God, while 18% believe in a universal spirit or higher power

  • @shyguyry2033
    @shyguyry2033 38 хвилин тому

    i dont think he actually said anything of meaning. he used a bunch of buzz words he heard from the Daily Wire, and regurgitated them. he wants to display reality as this impossible to figure out thing. but ultimately HIS inability to understand the universe and facts and laws about it, doesnt mean there arent people who do.

  • @GRAHFMETAL
    @GRAHFMETAL 39 хвилин тому

    I spent 2 years in a patrol base in Afghanistan with 16 other other soldiers. 11 of us were Atheists when we got there. 13 of us were Atheists when we left

  • @1020kerry
    @1020kerry 41 хвилина тому

    Go for the bird turf

  • @rodzalez3549
    @rodzalez3549 42 хвилини тому

    That first guy sounds like the definition of an incel.

  • @soozah
    @soozah 43 хвилини тому

    haha i’m not christian but these guys use slippery slope and all sorts of fallacies to disprove his claim. And the objective truth thing is bananas for this reason, imagine if you are asked if there are aliens in space, and you say , “ well probability wise i believe there are aliens in space “ and then they respond with “ well a belief that there are aliens doesn’t mean that it is true , there for it’s false” . it’s like throwing the baby out with the bath water. things in life are not only black and white , there is so much grey area to everything 🗣️

  • @IzzysTravelDiaries
    @IzzysTravelDiaries 44 хвилини тому

    I had several philosophy classes in uni. I learned 2 things. 1. I hate philosophy. 2. I think philosophy is stupid navel gazing by pretentious people who have far too much time on their hands.

  • @SkibidiToiletBrush321
    @SkibidiToiletBrush321 44 хвилини тому

    Hi you slay

  • @jimaspinall2927
    @jimaspinall2927 47 хвилин тому

    Gospels are anonymous. Why does he keep claiming otherwise.

  • @theartguy6776
    @theartguy6776 48 хвилин тому

    This caller is just a dumbed down Jordan Peterson cultist. Lame.

  • @courgette3401
    @courgette3401 49 хвилин тому

    I’m a socialist English woman. Probably more left wing than any of you but because I work in a school with 10 and 11 year olds I hold an unpopular belief. Out of a year group of 25 children we have 7 who present as trans, bi. Or transanimal. Think they are a puppy and bark in class. I absolutely believe that trans people exist but it is a really low % . We do not need to be asking people how they present. Children and teenagers are being given options they don’t need. About 1% is the guess for the number of trans people. Why do I have 25% of my class saying that they are. I was a very masculine child played with the boys . I know for sure that if I were a teenager today I would believe I was trans. It worries me. I have a friend who is a trans women. She hates being called a woman she is a trans woman. A different category. She thinks it’s ridiculous that trans women say they have periods or period pain. She thinks it’s disrespectful to all the beautiful women in her life to say that she has the same experiences as a born woman. I reiterate that I am generally very left wing and will always use the pronouns that someone asks but I don’t know why we should ask everyone their pronouns when it only affects 1 or 2 % of people. I honestly believe we will look back in 20 years and think we were mad. Treat all trans people with respect but don’t make it a bigger issue than it is.

  • @dorcia
    @dorcia 56 хвилин тому

    Chuck. Florida. Attack Helicopter. All I needed to hear...then, his intelligence completed the profile.

  • @DarkAlkaiser
    @DarkAlkaiser 58 хвилин тому

    The constitution doesn't have anything relevant to a specific relgiion in it XD It only has the statement that rights are granted by a vague idea of a gawd, none of which any religion I know of has this group of rights in it either. Certianly not the bible.

  • @sstratford123
    @sstratford123 59 хвилин тому

    I’ll have to give it to Forrest for not saying the word “like” a 1000 times. 👍

  • @SerranoSalazar
    @SerranoSalazar Годину тому

    "After generations and generations of wickedness, even the babies were being born wicked". Actual quote from a bible thumper when questioned about his baby killing deity. It would be funny if it weren't so sad.

  • @InvisibleLad007
    @InvisibleLad007 Годину тому

    I understand, academically, why religions exist. They serve as powerful vector for culture and social control. That doesn't mean I have to subscribe to one. Another good point being made here is that when religion is not compulsory plenty of people are going to opt out. The indoctrination aspect (which religions of all stripes engage in) is key.

  • @sstratford123
    @sstratford123 Годину тому

    I’m an atheist and majored in psychology. Everyone has a belief system. Not always religion but could be based on reason, common sense and facts. Which is inherently a belief system.

  • @CoreyHart-mz6gw
    @CoreyHart-mz6gw Годину тому

    "as far as we know" wouldn't be objective fact. It is theoretically possible to keep the brain and body alive and subsequently reattach them. Regardless of whether or not we have the ability to do so, it is not objectively true that decapitation always results in death.

  • @blakewalker84120
    @blakewalker84120 Годину тому

    Regarding relationships with fetuses. Consider: Every day you walk into a bar and have a drink. Every day a beautiful woman comes into the same bar and sits near you while she has a drink. You never have a conversation with her. Sometimes you talk, sometimes you even talk to her, but she never engages. She just finishes her drink and leaves without ever saying a word or even looking in your direction. After a few weeks, you start telling everybody that you have a relationship with her. is it true? Do you have a relationship with this person who has never spoken to you, never shared her thoughts with you, never even responded with a word or even a look? Can you claim "Well, she's heard my voice a lot and she can probably recognize my voice by now, so yeah, we're in a relationship"? Of course not. If you think you have a relationship with her, you're wrong. It's all in your own mind. You IMAGINE a relationship that you don't have. Believing you have a relationship with a person who barely even knows you exist might even make you a stalker. And that's all a father has with a developing fetus. The imagination of a relationship with a "person" (who isn't really a person by any definition outside of a couple insane religious court rulings) that barely even knows you exist, very briefly, and only while you're making untilligle noises near it. That doesn't diminish the love you have for your growing child, or the anticipation of sharing your life with your child, raising them, loving them, caring for them, and all that the future holds. But it's clearly not yet a relationship.